October 2015

Looking through the Kona splits of the Pros, one odd result caught my eye: Shiao-Yu Li, the first Taiwanese athlete to qualify for Kona as a Pro, has splits up to 25.3 miles of the run, but no finish. I was intrigued: Was there a last minute meltdown in the finish chute? I started to ask around and found that I was not the only one who wondered what was going on. Fellow Pro Ruth Brennan-Morrey remarked:

I’m curious: I came out of the water with Shiao-Yu Li. She left T1 first, then she was 15 minutes up from me at mile 11.4! In the end, my bike split is 5 minutes faster than hers, so I should have passed her. I never saw her.

7th place finisher Sarah Piampiano said:

I’ve had a slow 1:10 swim, but I thought I’d still be faster than Shiao-Yu. I was a bit surprised when I overtook her on the Queen K, but focused on my race.

Taking a Wrong Turn

Shiao-Yu’s splits also offer an explanation of what likely happened: After T1 she wasn’t registered before 11.4 miles on the bike, she didn’t have any splits at the 5 mile and 7.8 mile marks. All of a sudden she had a big gap to Ruth, and while she swam about 20 minutes slower than Daniela Ryf, she was only 9 minutes behind at the 11.4 mile bike split. 

Shiao-Yu Li on the bike in Kona 2015 (Credit: Herbert Krabel, Slowtwitch, used with permission)

It’s pretty obvious that Shiao-Yu must have cut some part of the early course. Her friend and manager Trisha Chen relates what happened: 

Shiao-Yu is a person with very very poor sense of direction. After jumping on her bike and starting to chase others, she unfortunately missed the first 8 K of bike course. The accident happened because when she was about to turn to the right following a volunteer’s direction, another volunteer told her to go to the left.

We all knew that recognizing the course is athlete’s responsibility, however, sometimes the race has been very tense and mistakes might be made by both volunteers and athlete.

Her description is not 100% clear, maybe Shiao-Yu Li turned left coming up Makala Blvd out onto the Queen K instead of starting the loop through town. Another possibility is that she made a U-turn on the Queen K instead of turning right onto Palani Road and then down to the “Hot Corner”, cutting a major part of the loop through town that normally ends with a U-turn at the end of Kuakini Highway. Kona seems to be a pretty simple course to follow, especially considering that Shiao-Yi raced Kona before as an agegrouper. But an inadvertent wrong turn during the race seems much more plausible to me than an intentional course cutting since that is very easy to detect in Kona. Shiao-Yu must must have been confused about the directions and probably just went the wrong way.

Trisha continues:

Pretty soon she thought she might have been mislead and missed some kilometers in town because some stronger swimmers came up behind her. She immediately called upon one referee who was at around 10-20K on bike course and told him she thought she might have missed the previous course. The referee asked her whether she was sure about it or not. And he told her that since no one reported this and he did not know what to do and since she did not get a penalty back then, she should keep going. She even went to the penalty tent to ask if she could redeem the missing course by adding extra time. But since she did not receive any punishment from any referee, she could not do anything but keep going.

Shiao-Yu felt very very uncomfortable during the whole 180K. She wants to compete in honor and honesty!!

It’s probably during the discussion in one of the penalty tents that Shiao-Yu was overtaken by Ruth. The discussion must have cost a fair bit of time as well: In the end, her 2015 bike time (about 5:40 if you add 15 minutes for the 8k she missed) was slower than her 2012 time of 5:29:31 when she participated as an age grouper.

Still Finishing After All

Back in T2, Shiao-Yu tried again to correct her mistake:

After retuning to T2, she spent almost 20 minutes to find different referees, confessed to them that she was missing the course. However, since no referee or no one accused her upon his matter, it is only Shiao-Yu’s confession and honesty to be the evidence.

We are hoping that there is another way to redeem such mistakes (adding extra times…) so that athletes can still have a second chance to finish the race. After all, athlete all fought hard to get to Kona.

But the rules for not following the course are very clear for Ironman races: 

Section 2.01 GENERAL BEHAVIOR

Each athlete must:

(k)  Follow the prescribed course. It is the athlete’s responsibility to know the course. Athletes must cover the prescribed course in its entirety. Failure to do so will result in a disqualification.

Basically, the rulebook does not offer any way for her to correct the mistake she made, even if it allows for her to continue the race:

Section 3.03 DISQUALIFICATION

(a) […] If disqualified, an athlete may finish the Race unless otherwise instructed by a Race Referee.

(c) […] Neither timing splits nor Race results will be listed for disqualified athletes.

Her result would still be a DQ, but she wanted to continue:

But Shiao-yu never quit a single triathlon race before in the past 13 years, even when she was hurt in races. In her mind, no matter what happened, she would do her best and manage to run to the finish line. So she expressed her strong desire to finish this race anyway. 

After Shiao-Yu continued the race, she ran quite well and you could see her cross the line in the live coverage. Some results show her completing the run in 3:24, for now the “official” Athlete Tracker on Ironman.com lists her as a DNF. Even though she is disappointed with this year’s race, she looks forward to the next season:

Shiao-Yu felt comfortable about her strength and power and she believed that she still has great room to be improved. She has been much motivated to prepare to go back to Kona again.

While Shiao-Yu is struggling to swim well after being hit by a motorcycle while in high school, she has been steadily improving on the run. She probably needs some off-time after Kona. In order to get enough points to qualify, she had to race five Ironman races this season: Malaysia (4th), Taiwan (4th), Lanzarote (4th), UK (5th) and Japan (1st) – all before racing Kona 2015! If she manages to step up to finish more often on the podium, she has a good chance to qualify again for Kona. Hopefully she’ll have a better race then!

A big thank you to everyone who helped with this article, especially Trisha Chen for sharing Shiao-Yu’s perspective (and Caroline Livesey for putting her in touch with me) and Herbert Krabel (Slowtwitch) for permission to use the photo.

With the Top 16 of the women in, here are a few observations about the women’s bike leg:

• The bike for the women has been very fast, most of the women raced considerable faster than their expected time.
• Best relative performances have been by Mareen Hufe (6:45 faster) and Michelle Vesterby (7:18 faster).
• Only Carolin Steffen has been considerably slower than what I would have expected based on her previous times (11 minutes slower). Susie Cheetham was slower by four minutes, but is still in a good position for a Top 10 finish.

Top 10 Projection

Here are the current projections for Top 10 on the female side (with Angela Naeth a DNF):

1. Daniela Ryf SUI 09:02:12
2. Rachel Joyce GBR 09:10:21
3. Jodie Swallow GBR 09:13:37
4. Liz Blatchford AUS 09:19:07
5. Mary Beth Ellis USA 09:20:08
6. Camilla Pedersen DEN 09:20:51
7. Michelle Vesterby DEN 09:20:53
8. Lucy Gossage GBR 09:23:35
9. Caroline Steffen SUI 09:24:06
10. Susie Cheetham GBR 09:27:34

Bike Analysis

Rank	Name	Nation	Bike	Bike Diff
1	Daniela Ryf	SUI	04:50:46	-04:37
2	Angela Naeth	CAN	04:54:54	-04:10
3	Jodie Swallow	GBR	04:58:48	-04:05
4	Mareen Hufe	GER	04:59:15	-06:45
5	Camilla Pedersen	DEN	04:59:17	-05:55
6	Mary Beth Ellis	USA	04:59:29	-04:43
7	Michelle Vesterby	DEN	05:00:41	-07:18
8	Rachel Joyce	GBR	05:01:29	-01:32
9	Lucy Gossage	GBR	05:02:40	-04:07
10	Annabel Luxford	AUS	05:04:00	02:46
11	Heather Jackson	USA	05:04:43	01:03
12	Liz Blatchford	AUS	05:07:25	-03:39
13	Caroline Steffen	SUI	05:10:53	11:01
14	Dede Griesbauer	USA	05:11:08	-05:53
15	Susie Cheetham	GBR	05:14:33	04:42
16	Elizabeth Lyles	USA	05:18:32	02:22

After the first men are in, here are some observations:

• Similar to the swim, conditions were pretty typical for Kona – meaning that a course record is probably not in the cards.
• So far Maik Twelsiek posted the fastest bike split in 4:25:10, nearly 6 minutes than expected
• Sebastian Kienle rode a bit quicker than Jan Frodeno, but was still 1:30 slower than expected.
• Jan Frodeno was more than two minutes quicker than expected, he is projected to be the winner this year. But of course the marathon still has to be run!
• Tim O’Donnell and Joe Skipper were 13:42 and 10:36 quicker than expected – hopefully they can still have a good run!

Projected Top 10

1. Jan Frodeno GER 08:12:50
2. Brent McMahon CAN 08:15:42
3. Frederik Van Lierde BEL 08:18:44
4. Sebastian Kienle GER 08:19:12
5. Andreas Raelert GER 08:19:39
6. Timothy O’Donnell USA 08:21:14
7. Andy Potts USA 08:21:35
8. Eneko Llanos ESP 08:24:02
9. Ben Hoffman USA 08:24:09
10. Marino Vanhoenacker BEL 08:25:27

Bike Analysis

Rank	Name	Nation	Bike	Bike Diff
1	Maik Twelsiek	GER	04:25:10	-05:42
2	Sebastian Kienle	GER	04:25:53	01:32
3	Timothy O’Donnell	USA	04:26:13	-13:42
4	Eneko Llanos	ESP	04:26:56	-05:51
5	Frederik Van Lierde	BEL	04:27:18	-02:49
6	Marino Vanhoenacker	BEL	04:27:26	00:57
7	Jan Frodeno	GER	04:27:27	-02:20
8	Brent McMahon	CAN	04:27:51	-02:20
9	Andi Boecherer	GER	04:27:58	-03:27
10	Joe Skipper	GBR	04:28:34	-10:36
11	Michael Weiss	AUT	04:28:34	00:53
12	Ben Hoffman	USA	04:28:51	-06:49
13	Tyler Butterfield	BMU	04:29:35	-06:42
14	Boris Stein	GER	04:30:48	-05:10
15	Andreas Raelert	GER	04:30:52	-04:35
16	Romain Guillaume	FRA	04:31:12	-08:18
17	Andy Potts	USA	04:32:41	-04:35
18	Cyril Viennot	FRA	04:34:27	-05:54
19	Igor Amorelli	BRA	04:34:56	-05:51
20	Lionel Sanders	CAN	04:35:17	-00:02

After the swim I did a quick analysis of the data. Here are a few quick points:

• The swim in Kona is always slow, this year it was maybe just a little bit slower than in the last years. The 2014 adjustment was -4:46, this year’s preliminary adjustment -4:58, 12 seconds slower.
• In the mens’s race we saw fast swims by Romain Guillaume (58 seconds faster than expected), Ben Hoffman (1:21), Paul Ambrose (1:20), Tim Berkel (1:47).
  But Sebastian Kienle had the best swim relative to expectations, 3 minutes quicker than expected!
• Slow men’s swims were by Dylan McNeice (even though he won the swim, he was 1:02 slower than expected), Brad Kahlefeldt (1:39), Brent McMahon (1:03),
  Two strong bikers also didn’t really have a good swim: Marino Vanhoenacker (2:37) and Maik Twelsiek (2:09)
• In the female race there were fast swims by Annabel Luxford (53 seconds faster than expected), Caroline Steffen (47 sec), Dede Griesbauer (46 sec) , Susie Cheetham (3:50) and Liz Lyles (2:25).
• Similar to Dylan on the men’s side, Jodie Swallow won the swim but was slower than expected (by 1:31). Meredith Kessler (1:05), Haley Chura (2:17) and Amanda Stevens (2:43) also don’t have the swims they were probably looking for.

Preliminary Swim Analysis Men

Rank	Name	Nation	Swim	Swim Diff
1	Dylan McNeice	NZL	00:50:48	01:02
2	Jan Frodeno	GER	00:50:50	-00:07
3	Andy Potts	USA	00:50:56	00:20
4	Christian Kramer	GER	00:52:21	-00:06
5	Nils Frommhold	GER	00:52:23	00:21
6	Tim Don	GBR	00:52:25	00:11
7	Romain Guillaume	FRA	00:52:25	-00:58
8	Jeremy Jurkiewicz	FRA	00:52:26	00:07
9	Timothy O’Donnell	USA	00:52:27	00:33
10	Andreas Raelert	GER	00:52:27	-00:34
11	Brad Kahlefeldt	AUS	00:52:27	01:39
12	Fraser Cartmell	GBR	00:52:28	-00:28
13	Denis Chevrot	FRA	00:52:28	00:31
14	Frederik Van Lierde	BEL	00:52:28	00:07
15	Ivan Rana	ESP	00:52:28	00:00
16	Brent McMahon	CAN	00:52:28	01:03
17	Luke McKenzie	AUS	00:52:30	-00:36
18	David McNamee	GBR	00:52:31	00:16
19	Ben Hoffman	USA	00:52:32	-01:21
20	Paul Ambrose	AUS	00:52:32	-01:20
21	Igor Amorelli	BRA	00:52:33	00:18
22	Tim Van Berkel	AUS	00:52:33	-01:47
23	Bas Diederen	NED	00:52:35	00:19
24	Tyler Butterfield	BMU	00:52:36	-01:06
25	Miquel Blanchart Tinto	ESP	00:52:36	-01:00
26	Sebastian Kienle	GER	00:52:36	-03:00

Swim Analysis

Rank	Name	Nation	Swim	Swim Diff
1	Jodie Swallow	GBR	00:55:04	01:31
2	Leanda Cave	GBR	00:56:08	00:24
3	Annabel Luxford	AUS	00:56:11	-00:53
4	Michelle Vesterby	DEN	00:56:14	-00:44
5	Rachel Joyce	GBR	00:56:14	-00:10
6	Mary Beth Ellis	USA	00:56:16	00:21
7	Liz Blatchford	AUS	00:56:16	00:05
8	Daniela Ryf	SUI	00:56:17	-00:36
9	Camilla Pedersen	DEN	00:56:17	00:12
10	Meredith Kessler	USA	00:56:17	01:05
11	Caroline Steffen	SUI	00:56:19	-00:47
12	Gina Crawford	NZL	00:56:21	-00:38
13	Haley Chura	USA	00:56:25	02:17
14	Dede Griesbauer	USA	00:56:42	-00:46
15	Julia Gajer	GER	00:57:39	-00:31
16	Susie Cheetham	GBR	00:57:43	-03:50
17	Laurel Wassner	USA	00:57:45	-00:56
18	Amanda Stevens	USA	00:57:45	02:43
19	Kelly Williamson	USA	00:59:58	01:42
20	Heather Wurtele	CAN	01:00:01	00:07
21	Elizabeth Lyles	USA	01:00:07	-02:25
22	Mirinda Carfrae	AUS	01:00:58	00:36